‘Ray Donovan’ packs an unexpected punch

The writing on the wall

I’ve been watching Ray Donovan, a Showtime series that sets a lot of scenes inside a family-owned boxing gym in Los Angeles. (It’s been running four years, but I’m on season two.) It’s a good show, but not so good it keeps my attention from the fight posters on the gym’s walls.

Fight night at Philly's Legendary Blue Horizon. (Photo via Creative Commons/Wikimedia)

The posters look real. They are the right size, the right red and black print, the right yellow (seemingly) heavy cardboard, fit for tacking to telephone polls or standing in store windows to promote the card. Like boxing itself, they’re solid but tacky.

Quintessential Philadelphia boxer

I haven’t been a fight fan for years, and I don’t know most of the fighters’s names. But one jumps out at me: Bennie Briscoe. I’d already seen Bad Bennie fight three or four times when I left Philly in September 1967. He lasted 20 years (66-24-5, with 53 KOs.), and beat some past or future world champions without becoming one. Wikipedia calls him “the quintessential Philadelphia boxer.” Ring ranks him number 34 of “the 100 greatest punchers of all time.”

I spotted Briscoe’s name on two posters. On one, his opponent is a fellow named Vinales. The other is named Elliott Miller, and the fight is at the Legendary Blue Horizon, on North Broad St. (I was there once, but I don’t remember who was beating whom.)           

Vinales could be a fighter’s name, I thought. But Elliott Miller? It sounded Jewish more than anything, and in the 1960s and ‘70s, what were the chances of that? It wasn’t even “Elliott ‘the Oxford Circle Assassin’ Miller” to boost the gate.

Looking for clues

It was an itch I had to scratch. Luckily, I knew how. I went to John DiSanto’s invaluable website phillyboxinghistory.com. I clicked my way to Bennie Briscoe’s record. There was Luis Vinales, twice. He decisioned Briscoe in Scranton, at the Catholic Youth Center, in April, 1972. Four months later, Briscoe KO’d him in seven rounds.

But no Elliott Miller, win, lose, or draw.

I had too much faith in John DiSanto to believe he’d left a hole in Briscoe’s past. My theory: Elliott Miller was a pal of Ray Donovan’s producer, and the producer slipped Miller’s name onto a poster as a gag. I needed confirmation and emailed DiSanto. I said I’d been watching Ray Donovan.

He replied immediately. He was also a Ray Donovan fan. The posters were mostly real. The show acquired them from the collection of Philly fight promoter J. Russell Peltz. Elliott had pulled out of a fight with Briscoe at the last minute, too late for new posters. “Neil Edwards stepped in on 1/12/71.”

So there it was. Without the internet I would have lived in ignorance or been driven screaming mad. Further research revealed Elliott went 11-6-4, a “tomato can,” in the parlance of the trade, a bleeder with poor skills. If Elliott was been a minor garnishment on Briscoe’s menu, Neil Edwards seemed less. He had no record anywhere.

From walls to windows

But what had drawn my attention away from Ray Donovan’s cavalcade of hurts and betrayals, infidelities and murders, to those walls?

Seeing Bennie Briscoe’s name had led me reflexively to the night in December, 1966, when he beat George Benton so badly “the champ of North Philadelphia” didn’t come out for round 10. Outside, on a cold Market St. sidewalk, a man behind me said, “Ain’t no George Benton no more.”

That rung bell echoed within me still. And that led to the friend with whom I’d attended the fight, then to his suicide in 1976, then to our meeting at a comic book stand in 1952, followed by an Ahmad Jamal concert in 1958, the Alameda flea market trip in 1970 — out of which I got my first published story — and then a Tijuana bar in 1963.

Our past is much of our present. Our memories are much of us. It almost seems that if you revisit the past often enough and if you probe it hard enough, you can make alternatives happen. The twists and turns of those revived dramas are more compelling than any teleplay.

Our readers respond

J. Russell Peltz

of Fairmount/ Philadelphia, PA on August 31, 2016

Bob: It was Ned Edwards, not Neil. Miller was not a tomato can, rather a tough nut. But no one was tougher than Briscoe.

Miller came to town the week before for the pre-fight physical and press conference. When I went to drive him back to the train station, Briscoe jumped in the back seat, since he needed a ride home. I knew there was trouble. So Miller starts yapping about how well he was doing in camp with Jimmy Dupree, a light-heavyweight of note. So Briscoe chimes in: "I ran that butch (Dupree) out of camp when I was in the Catskills." Right then I knew I had lost my main event.

When Miller got to the train and got out of the car, I said to Briscoe: "Why in the world would you say that to him?" Bennie just shrugged.

That night, or maybe the very next night, I get a call from Miller's manager, telling me Miller hurt himself and cannot fight the next week. So they gave me Ned Edwards, who was a light-heavy but who couldn't fight much, and Briscoe KO'd him in two rounds.

Author's Response

Thanks for taking the trouble to write and for straightening me out on Mr. Miller. That’s a good story. My article could have been worse. When I learned the posters were from your collection, I assumed “estate sale” and almost wrote “the late J. Russell Peltz.” Luckily the fact-checker in my brain took control of that.

Did you ever see my other piece on Philadelphia boxing. This “passion” has been revived somewhat in recent years, since I’ve added hitting a heavy bag to my work-out routines. As a 6’3” Seniors super-middleweight, I could be a contenduh, except my cardiologist has said I can’t hit anything that hits back.

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Want previews of our latest stories about arts and culture in Philadelphia? Sign up for our newsletter.