When, in 2005, my high school classmate Dan Rottenberg asked me to contribute to BSR, I had already enjoyed the honor of participating in Dan’s past enterprises, first as an occasional contributor to the Welcomat and later as the regular music columnist for the ill-fated Seven Arts magazine. I was delighted then and continue to be delighted today to again have the opportunity to express my views about music.
Because of my parents’ love for Beethoven, Mozart, and the like, I grew up surrounded by recordings and radio broadcasts of classical music. Foremost among the gods of my childhood were Franklin Roosevelt (even though he died when I was three), Duke Snider, and Arturo Toscanini.
Although neither of my parents was a practicing musician, somehow I got the idea in my head very early on that I was supposed to be a conductor. I have vivid memories of standing on a little podium, using the New Yorker magazine as a score, and waving my arms around during a radio broadcast, egged on by the accolades of my grandparents.
I went on to major in music at Columbia College, and then to earn a Ph. D. in music history from the University of California at Berkeley. Although I took a conducting course while at Columbia that allowed me to conduct the student orchestra now and then, the summer between college and graduate school was both the zenith and nadir of my short-lived conducting career.
I somehow got accepted to the choral conducting program at the Tanglewood Music Festival. This meant that from time to time I got to conduct what was, for those eight short weeks, one of the world’s strongest choruses. One afternoon near the end of the session I was allowed to conduct, in its entirety, the monumental fugue that ends the Gloria of Mozart’s Mass in C Minor. There I was, waving my arms around on a real podium using a real score, carried along by wave after wave of Mozart’s ecstatic music.
I went on to join the music faculty at Penn for seven years, but, even though I published my share of scholarly articles and even though I like to think I was a very good classroom teacher, it soon became clear to my colleagues— well before I admitted it myself — that I was not suited for academic life, either. Instead of being the good little classical musicologist I been hired to be, I spent as much time as I could in Penn’s electronic music studio playing with tape loops, the new Moog synthesizer, and a state of the art PDP-8 computer — it had 8K of RAM!— and before long I found myself out of academia and starting a career as a software developer, one that I happily practiced until my retirement at the end of 2009.
My departure from Penn was a bittersweet moment, though, because by then I had realized that I was hopelessly out of my league. I knew that preparing a piece like the Stravinsky Mass (one of our assignments) was well beyond my abilities and that I couldn’t ever hope to compete with my fellow students, who came from places like Julliard, Indiana University and the Oberlin Conservatory.
It was painful at the time, but in retrospect my relationship to music immediately became much happier. I’ve continued to sing in choruses at Penn ever since then and, as I have all my life, I still take weekly piano lessons. But despite whatever practical training I may have received as a musician and despite my academic credentials, I regard myself as an enthusiastic and highly opinionated amateur who is lucky enough to have been given a public forum to express his views.
| Why piano students cry |
August 07 2010 |
Somewhere in the world, a student cries at a piano lesson every 21 seconds. Why all this anguish? I believe that the emotional power of the classical piano literature itself is a powerful contributing factor. I speak from agonizing personal experience.
|
|
| Varèse festival in New York |
July 26 2010 |
Edgard Varèse’s music has no melodies and virtually no tonal implications; it’s all wild, intense blocks of sound filling up musical and physical space. New York audiences went wild over it, and so did I.
The Complete Works of Edgard Varèse. International Contemporary Ensemble and New York Philharmonic. July 19-20, 2010 at Alice Tully Hall and Avery Fisher Hall, Lincoln Center, Broadway and 65th St., New York. new.lincolncenter.org/live/index.php/lcf-2010-varese.
|
|
| Dutoit’s masterful Mahler Third |
June 15 2010 |
Dan Coren buys rush tickets to the Mahler’s Third and, too late, realizes what Charles Dutoit has meant to the Philadelphia Orchestra: “I hadn’t fully understood this aspect of the work until Dutoit’s calm, spacious, evenly paced reading of it revealed it to me at this concert.”
Philadelphia Orchestra: Mahler, Third Symphony. Mihoko Fujimura, mezzo-soprano; Charles Dutoit, conductor. June 10-12, 2010 at Verizon Hall, Kimmel Center, Broad and Spruce Sts. (215) 893-1955 or www.philorch.org.
|
|
| Utopia on earth: Choral singing |
May 31 2010 |
Does analytical thought add value to one’s enjoyment of music? Dan Coren examines his experience as a choral singer in his continuing attempt to answer this baffling question.
|
|
| Listening to music: Aesthetics or psychology? |
April 27 2010 |
What constitutes beauty in music? How do the conscious and unconscious interact when we make aesthetic judgments? Is a Beethoven quartet in some way a more worthy experience than Steve Reich’s Music for 18 Musicians?
|
|
| Reich, Glass and Bryars at Annenberg |
March 09 2010 |
The Zellerbach's dry acoustics and a battery of mirambas and xylophones almost swamped the Philadelphia Singers' delivery of Steve Reich's You Are. And I loved every minute of it.
Philadelphia Singers, Relâche and Orchestra 2001: Steve Reich, You Are; Philip Glass, Persephone; Gavin Bryars, Laude 22 & 23. David Hayes, conductor. March 6, 2010 at Zellerbach Theater, Annenberg Center, 3680 Walnut St. (215) 898-3900. or www.pennpresents.org.
|
|
| Orchestra’s new season (good news) |
February 27 2010 |
The Philadelphia Orchestra's newly announced 2010-2011 season is the most attractive I have seen in years, a felicitous blend of standard repertory and new music.
Philadelphia Orchestra: 2010-11 season announcement. www.philorch.org.
|
|
| The Orchestra’s inane marketing |
February 06 2010 |
Against his better judgment, Dan Coren reads a mailing from the Philadelphia Orchestra. Looking for something new? Don’t open this brochure!
|
|
| Bruce Nauman’s ‘Notations’ at the Art Museum (2nd review) |
January 09 2010 |
Philadelphia’s art critics and Art Museum guards sneer at Bruce Nauman’s sound installations, but to Dan Coren they evoke the hip, modern sounds of beautiful music and cocktail conversation.
“Notations/Bruce Nauman.” Through April 4, 2010 at Philadelphia Museum of Art, 26th St. and Benjamin Franklin Pkwy. (215) 763-8100 or www.philamuseum.org.
|
|
| Concerts to watch in 2009-10 |
September 08 2009 |
Dan Coren, liberated from his obligations to orchestral music for the first time in years, previews a sumptuous season of chamber music, jazz, and contemporary music.
|
|
| Beethoven’s ‘Appassionata’ turning point |
August 15 2009 |
I used to sneer when that superficial crowd-pleaser Horowitz sat down to play Beethoven. But getting reacquainted with the “Appassionata” through Horowitz recordings lately made me think more about the circumstances that brought Beethoven’s groundbreaking sonata into being.
|
|
| Composing vs. writing about music (a reply) |
July 21 2009 |
If I had Beeri Moalem’s talent and vision as a composer and player, I wouldn’t even bother to write about music. But when you're expressing ideas, you must accept a certain amount of responsibility for facts.
|
|
| Composing music: A reply to Beeri Moalem |
July 13 2009 |
Dan Coren, responding to Beeri Moalem’s recent article, “So You Want To Compose Serious Music?”, finds it “a mishmash of half-baked ideas and some very odd perceptions of music history.”
|
|
| Chamber Orchestra turns cautious |
May 24 2009 |
After two seasons of adventurous programming, the Chamber Orchestra of Philadelphia has reacted to hard economic times with a coming season that will offend nobody. Symphonic repertory in Philadelphia has become the musical equivalent of the menu at a high-end retirement community: pretty good, meal by meal, but deadly dull over the long run.
The Chamber Orchestra of Philadelphia. www.chamberorchestra.org.
|
|
| Mitsuko Uchida at the Perelman |
May 02 2009 |
Mitsuko Uchida’s piano recital at the Perelman was, in some surprising ways, a deeply unsettling experience. But in the end, she demonstrated why she is a musical legend.
Mitsuko Uchida, pianist: Works by Mozart, Beethoven, Berg and Schumann. Presented by Philadelphia Chamber Music Society April 27, 2009 at Perelman Theater, Kimmel Center. (215) 569-8080 or www.philadelphiachambermusic.org.
|
|
| Sonata form (Part 11): Recapitulation |
April 28 2009 |
Beethoven devoted most of his career to intensifying the inherent drama of sonata-form. Ultimately he drilled so deeply into its bedrock that the form itself became barely recognizable in his very last works. In this 11th installment in his series on sonata-form, Dan Coren moves on to the recapitulation section.
|
|
| Curtis Opera’s ‘Wozzeck’ (1st review) |
March 19 2009 |
Here I am in my mid-60s, having devoted most of my life to the study of classical music, and I still haven’t come to terms with the music of Alban Berg. The Curtis Institute’s production of Wozzeck was superb, but listening to it was an appalling experience I have no desire to repeat.
Wozzeck. Opera by Alban Berg; directed by Emma Griffin; Corrado Rovaris, conductor. Curtis Opera Theatre production March 13-18, 2009 at Perelman Theater, Kimmel Center. (215) 893-7902 or www.curtis.edu.
|
|
| Lucinda Williams at the Keswick |
March 10 2009 |
Dark though her subjects have been over the years, Lucinda Williams now gives the impression of being completely at ease with herself and her fellow musicians and reveling in 30 years of her own repertory.
Lucinda Williams. March 6, 2009 at Keswick Theatre, Glenside, Pa. www.keswicktheatre.com.
|
|
| Astral Artists’ ‘Musical Tapestry’ |
February 26 2009 |
So you want challenging new music that’s nevertheless comprehensible and digestible? Astral Artists’ “Musical Tapestry” offered young musicians who are not only talented but also eager to recruit converts to their unusual repertory.
“A Musical Tapestry”: Doug O’Connor, saxophone; Susan Babini, cello; Spencer Myer, piano. Astral Artists presentation, February 22, 2009 at Trinity Center for Urban Life, 2212 Spruce St. (215) 735-6999 or www.astralartists.org.
|
|
| Brahms German Requiem by Chamber Orchestra (1st review) |
February 17 2009 |
The Choral Arts Society’s performance of Brahms’s German Requiem was in many ways a cornucopia of musical riches. But the acoustics of the Perelman Theater made it as frustrating as it was satisfying.
Brahms German Requiem. Chamber Orchestra of Philadelphia with Choral Arts Society. Susanna Phillips, soprano; Randall Scarlata, baritone; Ignat Solzhenitsyn, conductor. Feb 13 & 15, 2009 at Perelman Theater, Verizon Hall. (215) 545-5451 or www.chamberorchestra.org.
|
|
| Sonata-form (Part 10): Mozart’s brilliant move |
February 07 2009 |
The development section of the finale of Mozart’s “Jupiter” Symphony ends with a move as brilliant as a Bobby Fischer chess combination. In the tenth installment of his series on sonata-form, Dan Coren contemplates this passage.
|
|
| Do happy musicians play better? |
January 17 2009 |
Does it matter whether or not musicians– especially musicians in a classical orchestra– seem to be personally enjoying the music they’re playing? Given a certain level of musical excellence, it’s really a very simple question in the end.
|
|
| Lucinda Williams and Bob Dylan |
December 14 2008 |
I can’t believe that the renowned perfectionist Lucinda Williams doesn’t know, in her heart of hearts, that her latest album, “Little Honey,” is a mess. Bob Dylan’s impact on our culture, on the other hand, continues to be as deep as Beethoven’s or Shakespeare’s.
Lucinda Williams will perform at the Keswick Theater in Glenside, Pa., on Friday, March 6th at 8 p.m. (215) 572-7650 or www.keswicktheatre.com.
|
|
| A music critic’s guilty plea |
November 15 2008 |
To loyal BSR readers waiting anxiously to find out how those augmented sixths in Mozart’s Jupiter and Beethoven’s Fourth Symphony work out: It's all my computer's fault.
|
|
| Glenn Gould vs. Roslyn Tureck |
November 08 2008 |
As a teenager, our critic Dan Coren fell so completely under the spell of the young Canadian pianist, Glenn Gould, that it took him more than 30 years to catch up with the great pianist whom Gould pushed off the stage: Roslyn Tureck.
A Romance on Three Legs: Glenn Gould’s Obsessive Quest for the Perfect Piano. By Katie Hafner. Bloomsbury, 2008. 272 pages; $24.00. www.amazon.com/Romance-Three-Legs-Obsessive-Perfect/dp/1596915242
|
|
| Susan Babini cello recital (review) |
October 21 2008 |
The end of Susan Babini’s cello recital represented some of the most honestly self-revealing playing I’ve ever heard.
Susan Babini: Solo Cello Debut Concert. Presented by Astral Artists, October 19, 2008 at Trinity Center for Urban life, 2212 Spruce St. (215) 735-6699 or www.astralartists.org.
|
|
| Susan Babini debut cello concert |
October 12 2008 |
Astral Artists protégé cellist Susan Babini will give her Philadelphia solo debut on Sunday Oct 19th at the Trinity Center for Urban Life. If Pablo Casals or Jacqueline DuPré had selected this program, the concert would have sold out months in advance.
Susan Babini: Solo Cello Debut Concert. Presented by Astral Artists October 19, 2008 at Trinity Center for Urban life, 2212 Spruce St. (215) 735-6699 or www.astralartists.org.
|
|
| Baseball or Beethoven? |
September 30 2008 |
Our music critic confronted a painful choice: The concert hall or the ballpark? Then Jimmy Rollins solved the dilemma for him.
|
|
| Sonata-form, Part 9: The augmented sixth |
September 27 2008 |
In Part 9 of his series on sonata-form, Dan Coren discusses one of the most sophisticated devices available in the toolkit of classical harmony: “For me, hearing a dominant seventh become an augmented sixth is one of the miracles of the natural world, something akin to seeing a chameleon change color.”
|
|
| Simone Dinnerstein: A concert not to miss |
September 23 2008 |
The young pianist Simone Dinnerstein makes a practice of playing complicated works and making them look easy.
Simone Dinnerstein, pianist: Copland, Webern, Bach, Lasser, Beethoven. October 24, 2008 at Philadelphia Museum of Art, Parkway and 26th St. Philadelphia Chamber Music Society, (215) 569-8080 or http://www.pcmsconcerts.org.
|
|
| Frank Zappa’s prophecy |
August 16 2008 |
An unexpected and much needed musical kick in the pants stimulates Dan Coren to revisit one of the great musical artifacts of the 1960s: Frank Zappa’s “Trouble Comin’ Every Day.”
|
|
| Two books on music and the brain |
August 02 2008 |
I recently revisited two provocative books about music and the brain. On second reading, Daniel Levitin’s hyperactive This Is Your Brain On Music is actually sloppy and superficial. Oliver Sacks’s thoughtful Musicophilia remains a low-key delight. This Is Your Brain On Music. By Daniel Levitin. Penguin, 2006. www.yourbrainonmusic.com Mus
| |
| Development sections (Sonata-form, Part 8) |
July 12 2008 |
In sonata-form, development sections celebrate the inexhaustible complexities of Classical tonality. Do they, like expositions, have a common underlying floor-plan? Or are they downright unpredictable?
|
|
| ‘Evolution of Sound,’ a unique website |
July 03 2008 |
Seth Brown’s website, “Evolution of Sound,” offers a perspective on the history of musical technology that you’ll find nowhere else. On this site, Brown has uncovered material that’s as much a part of my musical self as the essays I write for Broad Street Review.
|
|
| ‘The Rest is Noise,’ by Alex Ross |
June 08 2008 |
Nobody writes more eloquently about music (especially contemporary music) than Alex Ross. He makes me feel that I’ve wasted the last 20 years obsessing about Mozart and Beethoven when I could have been listening to Morton Feldman and Steve Reich. The Rest Is Noise: Listening to the 20th Century. By Alex Ross. 640 pages. Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 2007. $30.00. Eschenbach’s mysterious failure |
May 20 2008 |
How did Christoph Eschenbach get such wonderful playing out of musicians who don’t like him very much? Call me a naïve idiot, but even after all the anecdotal evidence we’ve heard, Eschenbach’s failure in Philadelphia remains a mystery to me. Philadelphia Orchestra: Schubert Eighth ("Unfinished") and Ninth ("Great") Symphonies. Christoph Eschenbach, conductor. May 15-17, 2008 at Verizon Hall, Kimmel Center. (215) 893-1900 or
|
|
| Sonata-form No. 7: Role of repetition |
May 10 2008 |
Should sonata-form expositions be repeated? Do you care? To the Classical masters, the question was critical. Repetition of the exposition was an occasion for dramatizing the power of the tonic key and their attempts to escape its gravitational pull. (Seventh in a series of essays about sonata-form.)
|
|
| Chamber Orchestra plays Mozart and Beethoven |
May 06 2008 |
I can’t think of a better antidote to the excesses of the Mahler Eighth than the Chamber Orchestra of Philadelphia’s performances of Mozart’s 21st Piano Concerto and Beethoven’s Sixth Symphony that I attended the following afternoon. Chamber Orchestra of Philadelphia: Mozart 21st Piano Concerto; Beethoven Sixth Symphony (Pastorale). Ignat Solzhenitsyn, conductor and piano solo. May 4-5, 2008 at Perelman Theater, Kimmel Center. (215) 545-5451 or
|
|
| WPRB: My favorite radio station |
May 03 2008 |
A 20-year-old classical music DJ on Princeton’s WPRB epitomizes this remarkable radio station.
|
|
| Three spring concerts to watch |
April 15 2008 |
Dan Coren recommends three imminent local concerts, one of which he will actually perform in.
|
|
| Schubert vs. Beethoven |
April 05 2008 |
Dan Coren meditates on Schubert’s Eighth and Ninth Symphonies, which Christoph Eschenbach will conduct in mid-May, and on the paradoxical co-existence of Schubert and Beethoven in the Vienna of the 1820s. No other composer's death left such a gaping hole in a world that might have been. Philadelphia Orchestra: Schubert Eighth (“Unfinished”) Symphony in B minor, Ninth (“Great”) Symphony in C major. Christoph Eschenbach, conductor. May 15-16-17, 2008 at
|
|
| Sonata-form (part 6): Mozart the juggler |
March 04 2008 |
In the sixth in his series of essays on sonata-form, Dan Coren shows how Mozart, in the course of riding his own piano concertos to fame and fortune, adapted the sonata-form exposition to his own dramatic ends.
|
|
| Orchestra’s 2008-09 season |
February 23 2008 |
Charles Dutoit announces a new Orchestra season that achieves levels of stodginess unheard of in Philadelphia since the reign of Eugene Ormandy. The Chamber Orchestra may offer better alternatives.
|
|
| Gilbert conducts Philadelphia Orchestra (1st revie |
February 12 2008 |
The Philadelphia Orchestra's concert of Hillborg, Bartok, and Nielsen proved that these days you don't need the standard repertory to attract a large and enthusiastic audience. The Orchestra has become a much younger group since Christoph Eschenbach’s arrival, and they play as if they’re having a ball. Philadelphia Orchestra: Hillborg Exquisite Corpse; Bartok Sonata for Two Pianos and Percussion; Nielsen Second Symphony. Emanuel Ax and Yoko Nozaki, piano; Alan G
|
|
| Israeli Jazz and Pierre Boulez |
January 29 2008 |
Jazz and Pierre Boulez— the perfect antidote for a classical musician’s malaise. Anat Cohen Quintet. Israeli Jazz Festival 2008, January 24, 2008 at World Café Live, 3025 Walnut St. (215) 222-1400 or www.worldcafelive.com. Orchestra 2001: Boulez, Le Marteau Sans Maitre. James Freeman, conductor. January 26, 2008 at Independence Seaport Museum, 211 S. Columbus Blvd.
|
|
| Tunes in sonata-form (Part 5) |
January 22 2008 |
In the fifth in his series on sonata-form, Dan Coren corrects some common misconceptions about the role of tunes in a sonata-form. Along the way, he re-introduces Haydn at his wittiest and most sophisticated.
|
|
| Critic’s alert: Catch these concerts |
January 19 2008 |
If you have a taste for the unusual – or for Mozart -- here are some concerts you won’t want to miss.
|
|
| Orchestra’s program gobbledygook |
January 01 2008 |
How, Dan Coren wonders, could the Philadelphia Orchestra’s program notes mangle the definition of a simple term like “octave” so badly? And how could they be so misguided about the nature of Mozart’s music? And haven’t you always wondered what “diatonic” and “chromatic” really mean? Read on.
|
|
| Stockhausen: The road not taken |
December 11 2007 |
At a critical point in his career, the composer Karlheinz Stockhausen took the wrong fork in the road. That’s a shame, because he inspired me to take the right fork.
|
|
| Hélène Grimaud plays Beethoven |
December 11 2007 |
The pianist Hélène Grimaud plays as if she has thought deeply about every single note. It’s as if Grimaud is hearing Beethoven’s lyrics in her inner ear. Philadelphia Orchestra: Beethoven’s Fifth Piano Concerto; Edgar Varèse’s Ameriques; Ravel’s La Valse. James Conlon, conductor; Hélène Grimaud, piano. December 7-8, 2007 at Verizon Hall, Kimmel Center. (215) 893-1900 or www.philorch.org.
|
|
| Understanding tonality (Sonata-form, Part 4) |
December 04 2007 |
In his fourth article on sonata-form, Dan Coren invites readers to sing along as he explains not only tonality— the sense of being in a key— but the concept of modulation to the dominant, the glue that holds sonata-form together.
|
|
| Chamber Orchestra plays Beethoven et al. |
October 30 2007 |
The Chamber Orchestra of Philadelphia, under Ignat Solzhenitsyn, established a benchmark for the interpretation of Classical repertory that will be hard for anyone to beat, unless it’s Solzhenitsyn himself. Chamber Orchestra of Philadelphia: Schubert Fifth Symphony; Beethoven Piano Concerto No. 2 (Fabio Bidini, piano); Haydn Symphony No. 16 and 102. Ignat Solzhenitsyn conducting. October 28-29, 2007 at Perelman Theater, Kimmel Center, Broad and Spruce Sts. (215) 545-5451 or www.chamberorchestra.org.
|
|
| Those slow introductions to symphonies |
October 16 2007 |
In Dan Coren’s third essay on sonata-form, he examines the way symphonies begin. Using the slow introduction of Mozart's 36th Symphony as a point of departure, he builds the first elements of a road map of a full-scale sonata-form movement.
|
|
| Orchestra’s ‘Rite of Spring’ |
September 25 2007 |
Christoph Eschenbach’s authoritative and ferocious reading of Stravinsky’s Rite of Spring more than made up for my sitting inside on a perfect autumn day. Philadelphia Orchestra: Tchaikovsky First Symphony, Stravinsky Rite of Spring. Christoph Eschenbach, conductor. Sept. 23, 2007 at Verizon Hall, Kimmel Center. www.philorch.org or (215) 893.1900.
|
|
| Best of the 2007-08 season |
September 15 2007 |
If you’re a Philadelphian whose tastes are eclectic and adventurous, and if you have a special liking for the French avant-garde of the 20th Century, this is your year.
|
|
| Classical music and golf |
September 11 2007 |
Golf, like Classical music, is based on a set of immutable rules and stylistic conventions. Haydn and Mozart regarded their procedural rules the same way Tiger Woods, the Beethoven of golf, follows the rules of golf— that is, almost as unconsciously as we regard oxygen.
|
|
| Sonata-form made easy (Part 2) |
September 01 2007 |
An elegant little tune from a Haydn Symphony contains in embryonic form all the essential ideas of sonata-form. The trick is learning to hear the same ideas on a time scale ten times as long. Listen closely and you’ll appreciate how a slight shift can send a tune off in an entirely new direction.
|
|
| You too can enjoy sonata-form (really) |
August 11 2007 |
Sonata-form is to me what the New Testament is to a born-again Christian. If I can sell you on the beauties and pleasures of examining how Classical music is put together, you’ll hear sounds of a magnificence you’ve never encountered before.
|
|
| Mendelssohn’s real tragedy |
July 14 2007 |
What would the world have been like if the Fates had been just a little kinder and allowed Schubert and Mendelssohn to know each other’s music as contemporaries? Mendelssohn was, I believe, the most musically gifted of all his famous contemporaries: the only composer in music history smart enough to assimilate Mozart’s music successfully. Yet his music makes we want to scream.
|
|
| The case for electronic music |
June 23 2007 |
Electronic music has become so accessible that a good deal of it is pretty primitive— the kind you might want your neighbor to turn down at 3 a.m. But this proliferation of new sounds strikes me a lot like 18th-Century musical Vienna must have seemed. All we lack is a new Joseph Haydn.
|
|
| Fresh air from the Chamber Orchestra |
June 21 2007 |
The Chamber Orchestra will devote almost half its repertory in the coming season to works by daring experimental composers, past and present. If Ignat Solzhenitsyn keeps up this sort of programming, perhaps Charles Dutoit’s arrival at the Philadelphia Orchestra won’t stultify Philadelphia concert life as much as I’d feared.
|
|
| Orchestra plays John Adams |
April 28 2007 |
I had the impression that the Orchestra had become a collective ecosystem, like a coral reef, teeming with the minute details of self-perpetuating organic processes. Has anyone at the Orchestra considered trying to hire Donald Runnicles? This guy is the real deal. Philadelphia Orchestra: Works by John Adams, Bruch. Donald Runnicles conducting; Janine Jansen, violin solo. April 20-21, 2007 at Verizon Hall, Kimmel Center. 215. 893.1900 or Kronos Quartet plays ‘Sun Rings’ |
April 28 2007 |
Sun Rings is a meditation on the Voyager space probes of the 1970s, full of furious action, accompanied by non-stop visual projections. I loved it. The audience loved it. Then we read the Inquirer critic's review. Sun Rings. Composed by Terry Riley. Kronos Quartet, April 19, 2007 at Perelman Theater, Kimmel Center. www.kronosquartet.org.
|
|
| Lucinda Williams (Round Two) |
April 17 2007 |
Dan Coren responds to reader comments about his paean to Lucinda Williams: “Do you have Google alerts set for Lucinda Williams? Surely you haven’t been reading my classical pieces in the hope that one day I’d write about her music.”
|
|
| Lucinda Williams discovered (belatedly) |
April 05 2007 |
Discovering the singer Lucinda Williams has exerted an Elvis-like impact on this classical critic’s musical taste. Although her latest album, West, is disappointing, Williams remains an extraordinary creative force: the thinking person’s country/rock star.
|
|
| Eschenbach's last hurrah |
March 19 2007 |
After a season marked by staid and timid programming, Christoph Eschenbach is going out in 2007-08 with a spectacular blend of tradition and novelty. With Charles Dutoit in the wings, apparently poised to take the Orchestra back to the musical equivalent of the Eisenhower administration, I fear next season may be the last Orchestra season like this for a long time.
|
|
| Penn Symphony plays Berlioz |
March 03 2007 |
I regard the Berlioz Symphonie Fantastique as a grisly accident on the highway of music history. It took guts for Penn’s student orchestra to perform it. Few other amateur orchestras could do as well with this hair-raising piece. Penn Symphony Orchestra February 24, 2007 at
Irvine Auditorium. 215-898-6244 or www.sas.upenn.edu
|
|
| Contemporary concert alert |
February 13 2007 |
Mark your calendar for these adventures in contemporary music with the Philadelphia Orchestra, the Penn Orchestra and the Kronos Quartet.
|
|
| Dianne Reeves, Jason Moran at Verizon Hall |
February 06 2007 |
Reeves treated her audience to an hour of lucid, swinging jazz in the grand classical style. Jason Moran’s relentless piano runs were less successful. Dianne Reeves, vocalist, and pianist Jason Moran. February 2, 2007 at Verizon Hall, Broad and Spruce. (215) 893-1999 or www.kimmelcenter.org.
|
|
| 1807 & Friends play Brahms and Mozart |
January 27 2007 |
Dan Coren's mania for chamber music was more than satisfied by the Mozart and Brahms performed by 1807 & Friends. Our critic also believes he may have found the secret behind the mysteriously unchanging demographics of Philadelphia's chamber music audiences. 1807 & Friends: Brahms C minor Piano Quartet, Op. 60, and Mozart E-flat major Piano Quartet, K. 493. January 22, 2007 at Academy of Vocal Arts, 1920 Spruce St. w
|
|
| The Orchestra’s loopy substitution |
January 16 2007 |
The Philadelphia Orchestra is substituting Vivaldi’s inappropriately cheerful Four Seasons for Mahler’s neurotic Kindertotenlieder. What on earth were they thinking?
|
|
| Why classical audiences don’t boo |
January 03 2007 |
Why are classical concert audiences so much more staid than their operatic counterparts? The answer may lie in the difference between a church service and a battle of gladiators at the Roman Coliseum.
|
|
| What was Mozart thinking? |
December 19 2006 |
Throughout his life Mozart remained basically clueless when it came to understanding other people’s musical capabilities or perceptions. Beethoven’s struggles endowed him with empathy for the lesser musicians who performed his pieces. But was Mozart capable of intentionally writing an easy piece? I don’t think so.
|
|
| Natalie Zhu plays Mussorgsky |
November 22 2006 |
Even in the thoroughbred world of concert pianists, very few have what it takes to play the piano version of "Pictures at an Exhibition" in concert. But Natalie Zhu took the piece beyond virtuosity to something approaching the mystical.
Natalie Zhu, piano recital. November 15, 2006, at Fleisher Art Memorial. Presented by Philadelphia Chamber Music Society, (215) 569-8080 or www.philadelphiachambermusic.org.
|
|
| Dylan the Romantic |
November 08 2006 |
What is Romanticism, really? If you won’t listen to the song cycles of Schubert or Schumann, you can find the answer in the song cycles of Bob Dylan.
|
|
| Orchestra's thin skin |
October 30 2006 |
Peter Dobrin, it appears, really does get under the skin of the Orchestra's management after all.
|
|
| Survival in the digital age |
October 18 2006 |
Bob Dylan’s career arc— from records to movies to DVDs to books to the Internet— is a tribute to the power and versatility of modern media. Other modern composers like Luciano Berio— not to mention old stalwarts like Beethoven— weren’t so fortunate. But whose work will survive the next time the electric power grid fails?
|
|
| Eschenbach pro and con |
September 26 2006 |
The Inquirer’s Peter Dobrin says Christoph Eschenbach should go because the Philadelphia Orchestra’s musicians don’t like him. Is Dobrin too young to remember legendary martinets like Fritz Reiner and George Szell?
|
|
| Critic's choices for 2006-07 |
September 20 2006 |
Contrary to his earlier declaration, our music critic finds a way to attend the Philadelphia Orchestra’s concerts this year after all. Some of them, at least. Here's his concert schedule for 2006-07.
|
|
| A feast from the Chamber Music Society |
September 11 2006 |
The Philadelphia Chamber Music Society reminds me of Southwest or Frontier Airlines competing against a legacy carrier: the Philadelphia Orchestra. The Orchestra can’t come close to meeting PCMS’s prices or to offering its richness of repertory. And not a single PCMS ticket is priced above $22.
|
|
| Chamber music lovers' alert |
August 10 2006 |
If you’re looking for an opportunity to hear some of the greatest chamber music masterpieces— works that are much too rarely performed— here are two dates to circle on your calendar in 2007.
|
|
| How Andrew Wyeth manipulated me |
July 20 2006 |
The Art Museum’s recent Wyeth exhibit moved my wife and me to tears. Only upon later reflection did we conclude that we’d been conned. From the audio tour to the paintings themselves, the enterprise was characterized above all by the art of calculation. “Andrew Wyeth: Memory and Magic.” March 29- July 16, 2006 at Philadelphia Museum of Art Dorrance Galleries, Benjamin Franklin Parkway at 26th Street. www.philamuseum.org.<
|
|
| Emanuel Ax plays the 'Emperor' Concerto |
July 03 2006 |
Beethoven’s “Emperor” Concerto, performed by Emanuel Ax with the Philadelphia Orchestra, Mann Center, June 21, 2006. www.philorch.org. All this, plus the Yankees and the summer solstice, too.
|
|
| Fresh insight into Eschenbach |
July 03 2006 |
In an old recording of Beethoven’s last piano sonata, our critic finds a link between Christoph Eschenbach and Thomas Mann’s fictitious stammering organ professor Wendell Kretschmar. And then he encounters Mitsuko Uchida.
|
|
| Pay to play on the Kimmel's organ |
June 03 2006 |
Contrary to what you read in the Inquirer, the Kimmel's "Pay to Play" organ event was no mere public-relations exercise. It was a showcase for a serious but often disrespected constituency: organists and composers of organ music.
|
|
| The Kimmel organ's debut |
May 29 2006 |
It was a pleasure to find a full and enthusiastic house at a Philadelphia Orchestra concert. But it took a novelty act to do it. The Kimmel organ’s debut concert itself was a sedate affair, notwithstanding the Gallic charm of Olivier Latry. Philadelphia Orchestra. Christoph Eschenbach conducting, Olivier Latry, organist. May 11-13, 2006. at Kimmel Center. www.philorch.org.
|
|
| Penn's student orchestra shines |
April 26 2006 |
Yet another surprising source of good symphonic music— this from students who don’t even attend a conservatory. Penn Symphony Orchestra. Brad Smith, conductor. At Irvine Auditorium, April 23, 2006. www.sas.upenn.edu/music.
|
|
| Why I canceled my Orchestra subscription |
April 26 2006 |
The Philadelphia Orchestra has never sounded better. Nevertheless, after scrutinizing our Friday “B” Orchestra series for 2006-07 and the competing Kimmel series schedule, we had to decide if the Orchestra was really worth more than $800 of our disposable income.
|
|
| The music and the money |
March 31 2006 |
So much money and so much work to produce a great concert? At the Orchestra, yes. At Astral Artistic Services, no.
|
|
| Eschenbach conducts Beethoven's Sixth: One small question |
February 28 2006 |
| One small esoteric question about Eschenbach's interpretation that's driving me nuts.
Beethoven's Sixth Symphbony. Philadelphia Orchestra, Christpoph Eschenbach conducting, at Verizon Hall, February 23-26, 2006.
|
|
| A lesson from Simon Rattle |
February 24 2006 |
| If a conductor possesses complete mastery of the music and can make an emotional connection with the players, magical things can happen— a power apparently not enjoyed by local music critics.
Philadelphia Orchestra. Simon Rattle conducting. February 2006. www.philorch.org.
|
|
| Jazz for the ages at the Kimmel |
February 02 2006 |
| These musicians go bravely where no man has gone before— even Mozart and Beethoven.
Mellon Jazz Fridays concert. Verizon Hall, Jan. 27, 2006. www.kimmelcenter.org
|
|
| Learning to love Christoph Eschenbach |
January 01 2006 |
| His conducting may not stick with you, but his music does.
|
|
| My debt to Birgit Nilsson |
January 16 2006 |
The great Wagnerian soprano died in December at age 87, unaware of her pivotal role in the writer's complicated relationship with Richard Wagner.
|
|